Back We Came Here to Forget Save as PDF
Chapters (50)
  1. Cover
  2. Dedication
  3. September 2008
  4. Penny’s Rabbit Is Sick
  5. Liz Sullivan Is Out of Here
  6. Penny on Christmas
  7. Liz Is an Expat
  8. Penny Has a Boyfriend
  9. Liz Meets the Madman of Belgrano
  10. Penny’s Hair
  11. Liz Learns Tango
  12. Penny’s Back Hurts
  13. Liz after Dark
  14. Penny Finds God
  15. Liz Is a Tiger
  16. Penny Is a Good Big Sister
  17. Liz with Her Eyes Closed
  18. Penny Knows All about Love
  19. Liz Is New Here
  20. Penny Is Having a Baby
  21. Liz Is Losing It
  22. Penny Is in Love for Real
  23. Liz Came Here to Forget
  24. Penny Is Getting Married!
  25. Liz Finds a Wonder Drug
  26. Penny Is Going to Be Fine
  27. Liz Is Not Your Little Project
  28. Penny Has a Daughter
  29. Liz at High Tea
  30. Penny Is the Best Mom in the World
  31. Liz Says Yes
  32. Penny Is Not a Criminal
  33. Liz Is in It Now
  34. Idaho Journal Sentinel
  35. Liz Crosses the River
  36. The After
  37. Liz Wants the Truth
  38. Where Has Penny Gone?
  39. Liz at the End of the World
  40. Penny’s Sister Takes the Stand
  41. Liz Is Ready to Talk
  42. Liz Has More to Lose
  43. Liz Can Explain
  44. Liz Is Not Liz
  45. Liz Gets the Full Story
  46. Katie Cleary Is Out of Here
  47. Epilogue
  48. Acknowledgments
  49. About the Author
  50. Copyright

My therapist, Gena, told me I was suffering from PTSD, a diagnosis I couldn’t wrap my head around; it felt somehow too dramatic, reserved for war veterans and refugees. At first, it was a bad night’s sleep, then it was a bad day on the hill, then it was a shaky month on the hill. I couldn’t sleep, couldn’t stop crying. I began taking Ativan for the panic attacks and Klonopin to sleep, usually after several glasses of wine, sometimes a bottle. My focus was shit, my thoughts were consumed. Late in the season, not long after the verdict came down, I crashed out on a sloppy training run and shattered my tibia. Then the panic attacks got worse. Luke and I broke up. Everything I’d ever consciously lived for, every reason I’d had for getting out of bed in the morning, was gone.

And that’s how Katie Cleary disappeared.

Liz Is Ready to Talk

TO SPARE myself, I ask Cali what she already knows about my sister. She recalls the broad strokes from the news coverage. The bizarre and horrifying story, the contentious, divisive acquittal.

“I remember feeling really bad for your family,” she said. “For what it’s worth, I believed you guys. I couldn’t understand how she could just walk after all that. Obviously I’m not an expert or anything, but I just thought there was no way something wasn’t seriously up with her.”

Since everyone in my old life experienced it in real time, I’ve never actually sat down and told anyone the story from start to finish. Halfway through, sobs come up from my chest, and the familiar signs that I might dissolve into panic present themselves: the coldness in my throat, the tightness in my chest. Cali asks if I’m okay. Do I want to keep going? I don’t need to if I don’t want to. But suddenly I do want to. I need Cali to know. I can’t hold the weight of it for another second. So Cali takes my hand and listens. I tell her about the breakup with Luke, the downfall of my skiing, and lastly, how I wandered into an airport and ended up here, with an alias and an apartment in San Telmo and an affair that’s slowly devolving into a disaster.

“Oh, honey,” she says, “exhale. That’s a lot.”

“I know.” I tense up, realizing too late that perhaps this was too much to lay at the feet of any new friend, and I haven’t even mentioned my pregnancy fear. “I’m sorry to just”—I mime a vomiting motion—“put that all out there.”

“Not at all,” she says. “I’m glad you felt like you could tell me.” She squeezes my hand and smiles. “I sort of can’t believe you’re still walking upright after all that.”

“Some days that’s about all I can do.”