She listened patiently then as he told her to come home, to get the hell out of there, to let the PI handle things from here. She agreed to everything, though she had no intention of going home without her mother. She would get out of Hastings, as far as the casino. But that was all.

Kurt was a liar, and he had tried to cast doubt on Reyes’s story and his intentions. He’d tried to implicate Watkins in her mother’s disappearance. The truth was, Reyes could have fallen into her bed last night. But instead, he’d turned around and left.

She hung up the call, then looked at Reyes.

“This is what my father thinks. And the PI,” she began. “After my mother went missing, Kurt knew to wait until all the other calls lead to nothing. Until everyone stopped calling in tips and the case got cold. Then he had his girlfriend, or whatever she is to him, come out of the woodwork with this bullshit story about passing through town the night of the storm.”

Reyes continued the story.

“And now—whenever you happen to find your mother—Edith Moore is first in line to collect the cash. That’s what I feared when we found out she was lying about being in New York.”

“And how could she have seen the letters on my mother’s purse? From across the street and through the rain?”

“Shit,” Reyes said. “I can’t believe I missed that. I was so focused on trapping her in the lie about her E-ZPass records.”

Nic nodded but then felt her face tighten.

“What?” Reyes asked, leaning forward, reaching for her hand.

“What if he knows where she is? What if he’s known all along and he waited for the other leads to die down so that now he could lead me to her?”

Reyes squeezed her hand tighter and smiled. “Well, who cares, right? If he helps you find your mother, that’s all that matters! We can go after the little prick later. I think we have to play this out—pretend you don’t know a thing about it and let him lead you to her however he plans to do it.”

Nic pulled away.

“What if it’s not that? What if he knows where her body is? And that’s why he knew it was safe to wait. That no one else would find her and that she . . .”

“Stop,” Reyes said. “Don’t let yourself go there.”

But Nic had to say it out loud.

“No one else would find her because she’d dead.”

Reyes reached in his pocket and took out a piece of paper. It was a copy, white on one side and folded in quarters. He held it out for Nic.

“What’s this?” She took the paper and unfolded it. It was some kind of invoice, something billed to the police department.