I scroll back to the first image. The one of her sitting on the floor, knees pulled up, hands covering as much of herself as she can. Her chin is bowed into her chest, her hair like a curtain hiding her face from me. But if I look close, I see her accusing eyes through that fall of hair.

There’s something about this girl that I can’t put my finger on. Something that’s got me thinking about her long after I should forget.

“Insurance,” I say to myself, standing. I turn on the printer and send all the photos to it. Listen to the slow hum and buzz as each one prints. Watch Natalie’s face as each slowly slides out, stacks on top of the last. When they’ve all printed, I put them in a locked drawer of my desk before going upstairs to jerk off.

The next afternoon, I go to her house. It’s a little after four and the shadows are already growing long. Winter days are short. I don’t mind them like most people do, though. I like the dark.

There’s no doorbell so I knock on the crooked wooden door, peeking in through the lace curtains of the window beside it. The kitchen is empty but there’s a light on deeper in the house. I knock again, louder this time.

“Hold your horses,” she calls out as the lock turns and she pulls the door open. She gasps, and the instant she sees me, she goes to slam the door shut.

I grip it, stopping her.

“Pepper!” she calls out.

I’m confused for a moment until I hear a lone, tired bark and the sound of a dog’s nails clicking against hardwood floors. Pepper barks again, sticks her wet nose into the narrow opening of the door. She’s old and not very ferocious from what I see.

“What do you want?” she asks. She’s got her back to the door so I can’t see her face, but feel her weight against it.

“I have something for you.”

“I don’t want anything from you.”

“Let me in, Natalie.”

“Why? So you can take more pictures? Freak.”

“That’s done,” I say. “Let me in. Last time I’ll ask nicely.”

“I said no—”

Before she can finish her sentence, I give a shove and hear her small, surprised yelp as she stumbles forward. I step inside. The dog wags her tail and I get a look at the tiny, ancient kitchen, then at Natalie’s startled face.

“You should close the door,” I say to her, unbuttoning my jacket. “You’re letting the heat out.”

“What do you want?”

I reach into my pocket, put the box on the table. It’s a brand-new iPhone.

“Here,” I say. “Upgraded to the latest model.”