Back When We Were Young
Chapters (58)
  1. Cover
  2. Title Page
  3. Dedication
  4. Epigraph
  5. Joey
  6. Joey
  7. Joey
  8. Sarah
  9. Sarah
  10. Joey
  11. Joey
  12. Joey
  13. Joey
  14. Sarah
  15. Joey
  16. Joey
  17. Sarah
  18. Joey
  19. Joey
  20. Joey
  21. Joey
  22. Joey
  23. Sarah
  24. Joey
  25. Joey
  26. Joey
  27. Joey
  28. Joey
  29. Joey
  30. Joey
  31. Sarah
  32. Sarah
  33. Joey
  34. Joey
  35. Joey
  36. Joey
  37. Sarah
  38. Sarah
  39. Joey
  40. Joey
  41. Joey
  42. Sarah
  43. Joey
  44. Joey
  45. Chapter Forty-One
  46. Joey
  47. Sarah
  48. Joey
  49. Joey
  50. Joey
  51. Joey
  52. Reading Group Guide
  53. Letter to Readers
  54. Discussion Questions
  55. Historical Note
  56. Acknowledgments
  57. Discover More
  58. About the Author

This was the one portrait Joey had ever begun that she’d liked. She loved the idea of a portrait, the turning of a person inside out. And she was good at certain frames: the backs of a mother and child walking away. A woman on a paddleboard with just her right cheek in the frame. But Joey wasn’t so good at portraits so exposed. Head-on. Her faces came out flat, her eyes uniformly vacant. No movement, Demetris had once agreed. No life. For some reason, this facial portrait was the sole interesting one that she’d ever produced.

Correction. That she’d begun.

Because in the midst of birthing it, she’d traded art for law. And when she’d returned to her old friend a year and a half back, it wasn’t with verve but with care. Like her art was something that could be shattered again.

She would do evil eyes, she’d contracted with herself, but without faces attached. Evil eye walls. Those safe, distant portraits, yes. But now she’d violated the contract. The past couple of hours, she’d sat in front of this strange, unfinished, distorted Leo face. She’d sketched and remembered and considered. Her cheeks blazed.

The same thought returned to plague her: I should change this to Grant. She flipped open her sketchbook and hashed out some ideas. She slashed a line at the jaw for him. Grant’s jaw was what people called chiseled.

Joey’s pencil hovered over the page. Quickly, she flipped it so the point aimed up. She busied the eraser over the jawline, hating her relief as it reverted to Leo.

Joey slammed her sketchbook shut. She eyed a pile of candy boxes. She could work on wedding stuff—the few items her mother had delegated. What she needed to do was dole Hot Tamales (Groom’s Favorite!) and Sour Patch Kids (Bride’s Favorite!) into welcome bags and affix the tags with calligraphy that had consumed hours in emails with an Etsy proprietress. Joey turned a Sour Patch box around in her hands, already tasting the salty sweet of a little bear on her tongue. Knowing how one bear would turn to one box, would turn to two, would turn to ten.

No. No no no no.

Joey knew she should feel her feelings—that was what she’d learned to do to defuse a binge. She bit her lip, reminded of that first binge, in the dark all alone after she was back at Penn and Leo and her grandfather were gone. But Joey didn’t want to feel her feelings now. What was she supposed to do, she wondered, when her feelings felt like they were killing her?