Back Scarlett and the Kiss Thief
Chapters (36)
  1. Scarlett and the Kiss Thief
  2. CONTENTS
  3. Chapter 1 – Operation Too Hot to Handle
  4. Chapter 2 – The Perfect Entrance
  5. Chapter 3 – This Plan is so Epic I Could Cry
  6. Chapter 4 – Put Me Down!
  7. Chapter 5 – Call Him Daddy
  8. Chapter 6 – Grounded
  9. Chapter 7 – A Classic Hunter Hunter Mess Around
  10. Chapter 8 – What. The. Actual. F Did You Do?
  11. Chapter 9 – You Little Pervert
  12. Chapter 10 – The Blowjob Phase?
  13. Chapter 11 – I Always Pictured it with You, Axel
  14. Chapter 12 – Jacob Miller in Black Boxers
  15. Chapter 13 – Why Snakes?!
  16. Chapter 14 – The Whole Football Team
  17. Chapter 15 – I Did Not Call Your Father a Dick
  18. Chapter 16 – Red Pandas
  19. Chapter 17 – Hoes Before Bros
  20. Chapter 18 – A Baker’s Dozen Men
  21. Chapter 19 –This Russian Chick is Amazing
  22. Chapter 20 – The Mascot
  23. Chapter 21 – Savage
  24. Chapter 22 – A Real Shit Older Brother
  25. Chapter 23 – The Kiss Thief Strikes Again
  26. Chapter 24 – Highly Illegal
  27. Chapter 25 – Knight in Shining Armor
  28. Chapter 26 – What the Heck is Happening?
  29. Chapter 27 – The Kiss Thief is Here
  30. Chapter 28 – Truth or Dare
  31. Chapter 29 – My Fairy Godmothers
  32. Chapter 30 – Mr. Halifax
  33. Chapter 31 – You’re It
  34. Chapter 32 – The OG Kiss Thief
  35. Chapter 33 – First Kiss Do-Over
  36. Axel & Jacob Bonus Story

“Tell me about your night.”

Was this some kind of trick?

She put her chin in her hand and waited.

“What exactly do you want to know?” I asked. Because I definitely wasn’t telling her how I’d snuck out in the first place. Yeah, this was definitely some kind of trick.

“You used to tell me everything, you know. You’d come home from school with a big smile on your face, excited to recount your whole day to me and your dad. I know that you’re older now. And maybe there are some things you don’t want to talk to your mom about. But I just...” her voice trailed off. “I’m here. Wishing you would tell me about your day again.”

Something about the way she said it made me want to cry. And the way she was looking at me like she truly did just want to hear about my night made me want to tell her every last horrible thing that had happened. It had been a terrible, no good night. And I really just needed my mom. My bottom lip started trembling again. And something inside me cracked.

“Sweetie, are you okay?” she asked.

“I had my first kiss,” I blurted out. And then I started crying. “But it wasn’t with Axel. And I really wanted it to be with him.” God, it’s all I’d ever wanted. And I’d messed everything up.

She pulled me into a hug and let me cry on her shoulder.

“Why doesn’t he love me back?”

My mom didn’t respond. She just hugged me tighter.

“It was supposed to be with him.” I didn’t want to tell her that I had no idea who I’d kissed. I was too mortified. All that mattered was that it wasn’t with Axel. And I might have been okay if I knew for sure it was with Jacob. But I didn’t remember smelling freshly cut grass. All the clues that the kiss thief left were scrambled up in my head. And I was pretty sure I’d hooked up with a drifter. I started sobbing harder.

“I know, sweetie.”

“I love him. And he’ll never feel the same way about me.” My chest hurt so much that it was hard to breathe. Axel hadn’t cared that I was giving my first kiss away. He didn’t care about me at all. And I didn’t understand how I could love him so much and he could feel nothing in return. He’d dated so many girls. What was so wrong with me?

My mom squeezed me tight. “Sh.”

I just wanted everything to stop hurting.