Back Scarlett and the Kiss Thief
Chapters (36)
  1. Scarlett and the Kiss Thief
  2. CONTENTS
  3. Chapter 1 – Operation Too Hot to Handle
  4. Chapter 2 – The Perfect Entrance
  5. Chapter 3 – This Plan is so Epic I Could Cry
  6. Chapter 4 – Put Me Down!
  7. Chapter 5 – Call Him Daddy
  8. Chapter 6 – Grounded
  9. Chapter 7 – A Classic Hunter Hunter Mess Around
  10. Chapter 8 – What. The. Actual. F Did You Do?
  11. Chapter 9 – You Little Pervert
  12. Chapter 10 – The Blowjob Phase?
  13. Chapter 11 – I Always Pictured it with You, Axel
  14. Chapter 12 – Jacob Miller in Black Boxers
  15. Chapter 13 – Why Snakes?!
  16. Chapter 14 – The Whole Football Team
  17. Chapter 15 – I Did Not Call Your Father a Dick
  18. Chapter 16 – Red Pandas
  19. Chapter 17 – Hoes Before Bros
  20. Chapter 18 – A Baker’s Dozen Men
  21. Chapter 19 –This Russian Chick is Amazing
  22. Chapter 20 – The Mascot
  23. Chapter 21 – Savage
  24. Chapter 22 – A Real Shit Older Brother
  25. Chapter 23 – The Kiss Thief Strikes Again
  26. Chapter 24 – Highly Illegal
  27. Chapter 25 – Knight in Shining Armor
  28. Chapter 26 – What the Heck is Happening?
  29. Chapter 27 – The Kiss Thief is Here
  30. Chapter 28 – Truth or Dare
  31. Chapter 29 – My Fairy Godmothers
  32. Chapter 30 – Mr. Halifax
  33. Chapter 31 – You’re It
  34. Chapter 32 – The OG Kiss Thief
  35. Chapter 33 – First Kiss Do-Over
  36. Axel & Jacob Bonus Story

The bottle slowed down until it finally landed on Ezra. One of the guys on my list that now, fortunately, only had ten guys left on it.

Sophie glanced at me and smiled before turning back to Ezra.

Oh no. What was she about to do?

“Truth or dare?” she asked.

He took a sip of his beer. “Truth.”

“Perfect,” Sophie said. “Have you ever received saucy photos via text from a redhead?”

My eyes grew round. That was way too specific!

“No?” he said.

“Why did you answer that like it was a question?” Sophie asked.

Ezra laughed. “Because it was weirdly specific. The answer is no.”

Okay, that had actually worked really well. My list was officially down to nine.

“Great, can I go again?” Sophie asked.

“That’s not really how it works...” Ezra started.

But Sophie had already spun the bottle. It landed on some girl I didn’t know. Sophie grabbed the bottle and tilted it a bit to the right.

The girl looked like she was about to protest.

But Sophie was already firing off her question for...Jack. Another guy on my list.

“Have you ever sent texts from an unknown number to a girl you had a crush on?”

I leaned forward, trying to see his reaction through the smoke coming from the bonfire.

Jack frowned. “No. Why would someone do that?”

“To keep their identity a secret,” Sophie said casually, like it happened all the time.

“You didn’t even ask me truth or dare,” Jack said.

“Oops.” Sophie spun the bottle again. “Let’s try this again.”

“What is Sophie doing?” Jacob whispered in my ear.

“No idea,” I said. But my voice came out squeaky and weird. Sophie had turned Truth or Dare into an interrogation of sorts. And it was kind of working. My list was down to eight now. If I could keep narrowing it down without kissing anyone else, that would be a major win.

The bottle landed on Noah.

“Truth or dare,” Sophie asked.

He pushed his shaggy hair off his forehead. “Dare.”

Sophie waggled her eyebrows at me and then turned back to him.

Soph, please, no.

“I dare you to kiss Scarlett and cop a feel.”

WHAT?! That last part didn’t need to be part of the dare. At all.

Noah set his cup down and stood up.

Jacob sighed next to me.

Seriously...why, Soph? Why cop a feel too? That was entirely unnecessary! I’d be able to tell from just the kiss!

I barely even had time to react.

Noah leaned down to kiss me.

But I was so very aware of Jacob and Axel staring from either side of me.

Noah’s lips pressed against mine.

And I knew right away that it was wrong. It probably felt wrong partially because of the guys next to me. But either way, I knew for sure that Noah wasn’t my kiss thief. There was zero passion.