Several men looked back at Thomas Coughlin. He smiled and waved, and a collective laugh rumbled through the room.

Danny wasn’t laughing, though. Danny was on fire up there. Thomas couldn’t help but feel a great swell of pride as he watched his son on that podium. Danny, as Thomas had always known he would, had found his place in the world as a leader of men. It just wasn’t the battleground Thomas would’ve chosen for him.

“They don’t want to pay us,” Danny said. “They don’t want to feed our families. They don’t want us to be able to provide reasonable shelter or education for our children. And when we complain? Do they treat us like men? Do they negotiate with us? No. They start a whisper campaign to paint us as Communists and subversives. They scare the public into thinking we’ll strike so that if it ever does come to that, they can say, ‘We told you so.’ They ask us to bleed for them, gentlemen, and when we do so, they give us penny bandages and dock our pay a nickel.”

That caused a roar in the hall, and Thomas noted that no one was laughing now.

He looked at his son and thought: check.

“The only way they win,” Danny said, “is if we fall into their traps. If we begin to believe, even for a second, their lies. That we are somehow in error. That asking for basic human rights is somehow subversive. We are paid below the poverty level, gentlemen. Not at it or slightly above it, but below it. They say we can’t form a union or affiliate with the AFL because we are ‘indispensable’ city personnel. But if we’re indispensable, how come they treat us as if we’re not? A streetcar driver, for example, must be twice as indispensable, because he makes twice what we do. He can feed his family and he doesn’t work fifteen days in a row. He doesn’t work seventy-two-hour shifts. He doesn’t get shot at either, last time I checked.”

Now the men laughed, and Danny allowed himself a smile.

“He doesn’t get stabbed or punched or beaten down by hooligans like Carl McClary did last week in Fields Corner. Does he? He doesn’t get shot like Paul Welch did during the May Day riot. He doesn’t risk his life every minute, like we all did in the flu epidemic. Does he?”

The men were shouting, “No!” and pumping their fists.

“We do every dirty job in this city, gentlemen, and we don’t ask for special treatment. We don’t ask for anything but fairness, parity.” Danny looked around the room. “Decency. To be treated as men. Not horses, not dogs. Men.”

The men were quiet now, not a sound in the room, not a cough.

“As you all know, the American Federation of Labor has a longstanding policy of not granting charters to police unions. As you also know, our own Mark Denton has made overtures to Samuel Gompers of the AFL and has been—several times in the last year, I’m afraid—rebuffed.” Danny looked back at Denton sitting on the stage behind him and smiled. He turned back to the men. “Until today.”