Laurie reaches out and shakes our hands. “I’m Laurie Keaton. My dad has a bunch of properties he rents to the school for student housing. I help him out.”

“Do you get a lot of curiosity seekers?” I ask. “I mean, people who want to know about the education of an American president?”

Laurie rolls her eyes. “Yeah, now and then people show up here expecting Mount Vernon or Monticello. We’re not exactly on the National Register of Historic Places. But I told my dad we should charge admission. Make a few bucks.” She leans back in her chair. “So you’re writing a book, you said?”

“That’s right,” says Garrett. “Investigative journalism.”

“Well, their old rooms are off-limits. Privacy issues with the current residents.”

I take a step closer. “Understood, Laurie. Do you have a tenant list for when the president and her husband were living there?”

“Future president,” Garrett clarifies. “And future First Gentleman.”

“What for?” asks Laurie. She’s looking at me.

“Background info about what things were like then. Whether Madeline Parson and Cole Wright interacted with the other residents in ways that predicted their great futures. Personal details. Stuff like that.”

Garrett leans in, turning on his best smile. “So, Laurie, do you have a list like that?”

“I don’t,” she says. “But my dad might. He’s a real hoarder and he’s doubled down since the break-in.”

Garrett glances at me. This is new.

“What break-in?” I ask, trying not to sound as interested as I am.

“A few days ago,” says Laurie. “When you came in just now, I thought you might be cops following up about it.”

“Somebody broke into your office?” asks Garrett.

“Yeah,” says Laurie. She waves a hand around the tiny room. “This is the scene of the crime.”

Now I understand why the file cabinets look brand-new. All metal. Heavy-duty. With combination locks. Laurie sees me looking at them.

“Yeah. The old cabinets were wood. Looked like somebody went at them with burglar tools, the cops said.”

“What did they take?” asks Garrett. I can almost see his reporter’s antennae shooting up.

“That’s the funny thing,” says Laurie. “Nothing.”

“Nothing?”

“Nope. But they destroyed the cabinets. Good thing our property insurance covered new ones.”

“Interesting,” says Garrett. “Do you think it was students?”

Laurie shakes her head. “There’s nothing in here kids would want. No money. No checks. All the financial stuff gets handled out of my dad’s office.”

Garrett taps one of the file cabinets. “So what is in here?” he asks.

“Maintenance reports. Water bills. Inspection certificates. Pest-control contracts…”

“No resident records?”

“Nope. But like I said, my dad might have that stuff. Somewhere.”

CHAPTER
17

We can’t resist a nostalgic tour of our own Dartmouth haunts, so we cross the green to the Baker-Berry Library and reenact our first kiss.