“Some of them,” he says matter-of-factly. “The good ones.”

I glance at the deputy. “Can you take him topside?” I hear myself ask. “I’m going to get the hostages.”

“Sure thing.” He glances at Tomasetti, who nods, then at Mast. “Let’s go.”

The deputy and Mast start toward the hatch. Tomasetti and I watch them go. Mast turns his head and smiles. In that instant, he looks like a frightened teenager.

“What the hell was going on here?” Tomasetti mutters.

I look at him and shake my head. “I’m not sure I want to know.”

Shaking his head, he shines the beam down the tunnel. “Let’s go find those hostages.”

Neither of us holsters our weapons as we begin walking. I look around for some familiar landmark. A step-up or alcove or door. But there are only brick walls and the oval of the tunnel. It’s as if I’ve never been here.

We’ve only gone a few yards when a scream echoes from the darkness. It’s the same voice I heard when I was down here earlier. It’s a bloodcurdling sound that rattles my nerves. But it also fills me with hope, because I know at least one of the hostages is alive.

I break into a jog. Tomasetti quickens his pace to keep up, holding the beam steady and ahead. We’ve gone only a few yards when I see the door.

“That’s it,” I say.

“Careful. He could have booby-trapped it.”

But I’m already pushing it open. I see two girls lying on the floor. Sadie is standing, one hand shading her eyes from my beam. I see terror in her eyes in the instant before she recognizes me.

“Katie!” she cries. “You came back!”

“Is everyone okay?” I ask.

The girl’s face screws up. “I heard the gunshots,” she chokes out. “I thought he killed you.” She lowers her face into her hands and bursts into tears. “I thought he would kill us, too.”

“It’s going to be okay.” I go to her, put my arms around her. The chain binding her to the wall rattles as she throws her arms around me. She begins to sob uncontrollably, her body trembling against me. “It’s over,” I tell her. “You’re going home.”

CHAPTER 24

Two hours later, the Mast farm is swarming with sheriff’s deputies, local police, paramedics from the volunteer fire department, and a slew of state Highway Patrol troopers. The coroner’s SUV is parked outside the slaughter shed. Midway down the driveway, out of the crime-scene perimeter, is a television news van from WCVK, out of Cleveland. A young reporter in a lime green raincoat is finger-combing her hair while the cameraman sets up lights.