Back Too Good to Be Real
Chapters (38)
  1. Title Page
  2. Copyright Notice
  3. Dedication
  4. CHAPTER 1
  5. CHAPTER 2
  6. CHAPTER 3
  7. CHAPTER 4
  8. CHAPTER 5
  9. CHAPTER 6
  10. CHAPTER 7
  11. CHAPTER 8
  12. CHAPTER 9
  13. CHAPTER 10
  14. CHAPTER 11
  15. CHAPTER 12
  16. CHAPTER 13
  17. CHAPTER 14
  18. CHAPTER 15
  19. CHAPTER 16
  20. CHAPTER 17
  21. CHAPTER 18
  22. CHAPTER 19
  23. CHAPTER 20
  24. CHAPTER 21
  25. CHAPTER 22
  26. CHAPTER 23
  27. CHAPTER 24
  28. CHAPTER 25
  29. CHAPTER 26
  30. CHAPTER 27
  31. CHAPTER 28
  32. CHAPTER 29
  33. CHAPTER 30
  34. CHAPTER 31
  35. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
  36. Also by Melonie Johnson
  37. ABOUT THE AUTHOR
  38. Newsletter Sign-up

Julia squirmed as her friends’ words sank in. Her heart twisted. Just a few days ago she’d wondered at the possibilities. Tried to imagine where things might end up between her and Luke by Sunday. Now it was Friday, and so much had already changed; more than she ever could have imagined. What would happen in a few more days when the game was over?

“Don’t worry about me,” Andie said, bravado in full force. “Julia’s the one with the lovesick string bean serenading her. It’s not like Curt is going to suddenly show up and pull some over-the-top romantic shtick like that.”

“I wouldn’t be so sure.”

Something in Kat’s voice caught Julia’s attention. She glanced up. “I don’t believe it.” The timing couldn’t have been more perfect. Like a stroke of divine rom-com intervention, Curt was there, skirting the other prep tables as he made his way toward theirs.

“Oh my God.” Andie paled. “You don’t think he’s going to sing, do you?”

Julia noticed the stack of large white poster boards he was carrying. “I don’t think that’s his plan.”

Sure enough, when Curt came to a halt in front of Andie, he didn’t sing. In fact, he didn’t speak at all. Instead, he held up his stack of poster board. A message was scrawled across the top one in black marker.

Andie read the sign aloud. “To me you are perfect.” She snorted. “That’s not very original of you, Curt.”

“At least give the man points for trying,” Kat said. “I don’t see Zach doing anything like this.”

“Yeah, give the lovesick butter bean a chance,” Julia encouraged.

“Butter bean?” Andie’s brow furrowed for a moment, then she grinned. “I see what you did there. Fine.” She blew out a sigh. “If you can listen to your string bean sing, I can read my butter bean’s notecards.” She waved her hand, indicating Curt should continue.

He eagerly flipped through several more messages, and Andie continued to read them out loud. Soon, his stack had dwindled, the floor around his feet littered with posters.

“Will you … Be my…” Andie paused, squinting at the new message. “Eno … suld?”

“I think that one’s upside down,” Julia offered helpfully.

Curt glanced at the board and grimaced. He fumbled around, hurrying to adjust it.

“Oh!” Andie exclaimed, rereading. “Plus one.”

He nodded, shuffling through the discarded posters on the floor. He picked one up and showed it again.

I’m not a perfect man. Julia smiled softly as she read it to herself. Maybe not, Curt. But you’re perfectly imperfect.

“All right, Curt,” Andie declared. “Yes. I’ll be your plus-one.”

He beamed and held up the last card. It had doodles of stick people cheering. Julia looked closer and giggled. He’d drawn them in Packers jerseys.