Half Title Page

Books by Roseanna M. White

LADIES OF THE MANOR

The Lost Heiress

The Reluctant Duchess

A Lady Unrivaled

SHADOWS OVER ENGLAND

A Name Unknown

A Song Unheard

An Hour Unspent

THE CODEBREAKERS

The Number of Love

On Wings of Devotion

A Portrait of Loyalty

Dreams of Savannah

THE SECRETS OF THE ISLES

The Nature of a Lady

Title Page

Copyright Page

© 2021 by Roseanna M. White

Published by Bethany House Publishers

11400 Hampshire Avenue South

Bloomington, Minnesota 55438

Bethany House Publishers is a division of

Baker Publishing Group, Grand Rapids, Michigan

Ebook edition created 2021

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means—for example, electronic, photocopy, recording—without the prior written permission of the publisher. The only exception is brief quotations in printed reviews.

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is on file at the Library of Congress, Washington, DC.

ISBN 978-1-4934-3147-2

Scripture quotations are from the King James Version of the Bible.

This is a work of historical reconstruction; the appearances of certain historical figures are therefore inevitable. All other characters, however, are products of the author’s imagination, and any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, is coincidental.

Cover design by Jennifer Parker

Cover photography by Todd Hafermann Photography, Inc.

Author is represented by The Steve Laube Agency.

Dedication

To all my readers named Elizabeth.
The sheer number of you inspired this tale of mistaken identity,
and I pray you enjoy it.

The Isles of Scilly

Prologue

19 JULY 1645
THE WATERS AROUND SCILLY

He was a prince at sea. That’s what John Mucknell shouted whenever battle was upon him.

Even before he’d stolen the East India Company ship, against whose deck his feet were now braced. Even before he’d presented himself and the John to the exiled Prince of Wales, offering their services against those blasted Parliamentarians who had taken over their country. Even before he’d been knighted and named vice admiral of this new royal fleet.

Pirate fleet, the enemy said. Mucknell’s lips twitched up as he watched the enemy craft close in. He was a prince at sea, a cockney. And, yes, a thief and a pirate. But it was the blighted Roundheads who had forced him to these straits. When his rightful sovereign was forced to barricade himself on an island to escape his enemies and found himself in desperate need of supplies, what course of action was there but to rob the ships passing by? And if the richest prizes were usually from the East India Company, under whose banner Mucknell had worked and kowtowed for so many useless years . . . shame, that.

“Admiral?” His first mate slid to his side, keeping his voice low. “There’s no way we’ll be able to slip by them into the harbor.”

“Nay.” Mucknell didn’t even need to raise his spyglass to see that three Parliamentarian ships had completely cut off the path to his base in the Isles of Scilly, off the coast of Cornwall. He’d met the Constant Warwick once already today, near Land’s End, and they’d both gotten in a few good shots.

Shots that had left them both weakened. But the enemy had now rendezvoused with the Cygnet and the Expedition. And Mucknell’s fleet . . . well, they were pirates. There’d be no help for him, unless he could lure the enemy into range of the isles’ batteries, but that wasn’t likely.

“Our course of action, sir?”

The wind blew, snapping the sails taut overhead and lifting strands of hair from Mucknell’s shoulder. His mouth ached for a sip of rum, but he’d not indulge it, not until this crisis was well past. His fingers twitched over the pommel of his sword. His mind, sharp and fogless, spun through what he knew.

His hold was loaded with the booty from a significant haul—one that the Prince of Wales would be most eager to receive: much-needed supplies of food and cloth and metal, casks of wine, spices.

Silver.

Mucknell’s fingers traced the circle of the pommel. Silver and more silver. Some of which he’d decided wouldn’t be among the cache he turned over. He’d branded his own name on the crate, making it clear to his men that this one wouldn’t be off-loaded with the rest. It was a man’s right, after all, to take a fee. And his would be the pieces already engraved with his wife’s name, as if they’d been made for her.

His gaze flicked toward St. Mary’s Island—so close, but too far to be of any help. Was his Lizza there, watching from a lookout? Or at their house on Tresco? She never breathed a word of her distaste for his new career. She just went where he asked her to go. Uprooted herself from their comfortable, if bare, life in London and followed him here to the very edges of England.

In moments like these, he knew she deserved better than a scoundrel like him for a husband. But she’d never say such a thing. Not his Lizza.

He’d get that silver to her. And the rest of the supplies to his prince. He’d outfox that triple-strength enemy bearing toward him. Somehow. He’d win. Because Vice Admiral Sir John Mucknell might be a pirate, but he was blamed well the best pirate these waters had ever seen.

As the closest of the enemy ships drew near, he pulled out his sword and held it high—the signal all his men would recognize as their cue to man their stations. And he shouted the words that were their battle cry.

“I am a prince at sea! I am the proudest man upon the face of the earth. I am an Englishman, and were I to be born again, I would be born an Englishman. I am a cockney. . . .”

He could feel the tension in the air that whipped around him, feel the energy of his men as they laid hold of their ropes and ammunition and torches and aimed the twenty-one guns on the starboard side toward the enemy, who had spilled the wind in her sails to slow and meet him. He could feel his crew waiting for his final cry.

“And that’s my glory!”

1

5 JUNE 1906
PENZANCE, CORNWALL, ENGLAND

More beauty than Lady Elizabeth Sinclair had ever thought possible beckoned to her—a turquoise sea, blue sky wisped with soft white clouds, birds cartwheeling through the air, islands studding it all with the promise of life she’d never had the opportunity to examine up close. The only thing standing between it and her was a woman whose eyes were growing worryingly watery.

The last thing she ever wanted was to make her mother cry. Or at least, that had always been the case before. Just now, something else had stolen that “last thing she wanted to do” ranking.

The last thing she currently wanted to do was give in to her brother’s machinations to marry her off to his school chum. Which meant she might have to harden her heart to her mother’s distress. “Mama . . .” She sucked in a breath only to find it as shaky as her mother’s. Hardening her heart was easier decided than done. “It’s only a summer.”

“I know.” Her mother pasted a wobbly smile into place and gave Libby’s fingers a squeeze. She’d scarcely let go of them since they debarked the train and made their way to the ferry. “And it’ll do you good. I know that too. Even so.”

She didn’t need to voice her concerns. She’d done that already a dozen times since Libby came to her with this plan a week ago. They’d never been more than a few miles apart. Libby had never been on her own—and even though she technically wouldn’t be alone now either, a lady’s maid who was only two years Libby’s senior wasn’t exactly a full-fledged chaperone. She’d know no one on the islands. She’d be lonely. What if something happened to her? What if something happened at home? Or with her sister? Proper young ladies simply didn’t run off to the Isles of Scilly for the summer by themselves.

The thing was, Libby had already proven herself an absolute failure at being a proper young lady. And when her brother had announced at breakfast eight days ago, with that frustrating “I know what’s best for you” look, that he’d spare her any further embarrassment and arrange a match with Sheridan, her options for the summer had shrunk considerably.

It wasn’t that Lord Sheridan wasn’t a good man. It was just that she didn’t really like him. He went ever on about archaeology. And she went ever on about the nature that his digs upended. And it only took about five minutes for both of them to be either bored out of their minds or seething at each other.

For the life of her, she couldn’t determine why Sheridan would have agreed to her brother’s plotting. Maybe he hadn’t yet. Maybe Bram meant to inform Sheridan of his brilliant new plan in the same heavy-handed way he’d informed her. Though why a marquess would feel any obligation to obey an earl, she couldn’t imagine.

Sheridan would object, if given enough time to really contemplate what Bram was demanding of him. That was how it always worked with Sheridan—he’d go along, follow her brother mindlessly for a while, and then he’d get that look on his face and declare, “I say, old chap. That is, what were you thinking of? That won’t do.”

She just had to give him time enough to come to the conclusion that she’d make him a lousy wife before her brother could get wedding plans made to the point that neither could back out without damaging their reputation. The summer to think about it—that was what Sheridan needed. She’d never seen him take longer than three months to wake up to Bram’s manipulations.

Never in her life had she disobeyed her brother though. Or, before that, their father. The very idea of it made her stomach squirm like the beetle she’d found digging its way through the garden at the inn this morning. But Bram had finally pushed her too far. It was one thing to inform her that she would be fitted for a new wardrobe for the Season and set up rules for what she could do when wearing it. It was quite another to simply state that he’d decided on a husband for her.

Mama sighed and turned her face into the breeze, toward the ferry. Her blinking was too quick to bespeak anything but a continued struggle. But her voice sounded steady—if a bit tight—when she said, “You’re going to have such a lovely time exploring and cataloguing. I only wish we knew someone on the islands. There are surely a few of our acquaintances holidaying there this year.”

Libby shot a look over her shoulder at her lady’s maid for fortification. Mabena Moon gave her that same muted grin she always did when they were in company with anyone else in Libby’s family. The one that everyone assumed was merely a polite acknowledgment instead of a sign of shared secrets. “I won’t be alone, Mama. Moon’s entire family is there. You read the telegram she got in response—they’re most happy to keep an eye on me.”

A beat of silence descended, punctuated by the ringing of the bell on the ferry calling all passengers to board. Her trunks were already stowed, her ticket purchased. All she had to do was walk up the gangplank and the adventure would begin. An entire summer on England’s most unique island chain. A subtropical climate that produced plants she’d be able to see nowhere else in the country. Birds her eyes had never beheld. Seals. Ocean creatures she’d not even learned the names of yet.

She could almost hear her magnifying glasses calling to her from her trunk. And her microscope sang a siren’s song in her ears. She had fresh notebooks waiting to be filled. Pencils in every shade, sharpened and expectant. Watercolors snug in their cases. A book on the classifications of life on the Isles of Scilly on the tip-top of her trunk, so she could snatch it out the moment she arrived in her summer cottage.

Then it struck—the tidal wave of uncertainty. What did Libby know of the world, of independent life? She’d never been away from home, not really. She was barely twenty. And if she couldn’t get on in the society in which she’d been raised, how did she expect to get on there, with strangers?

Her fingers were the ones to tighten around her mother’s this time. “Are you certain you don’t want to join me?”

Mama chuckled and released her hand. “Had I not promised Edith I would be with her for her lying-in, I would be there in a heartbeat.”

Mention of her older sister, the eldest of the three Sinclair children, made Libby’s lips twist into a wince before she could stop the reaction. Another reason this holiday had sounded so alluring when Mabena whispered the suggestion after Bram’s high-handed declaration last week. Her other option, if she didn’t want to spend the whole summer scowling at Sheridan across the breakfast room at Telford Hall while she waited for him to come to his senses, was to join her mother at Edith’s.

And none of them were ever happy when she and Edith were in the same room. “Give her my love. And if you wanted not to include her judgment on my holiday in your letters, I’d not complain about the lack.”

With another chuckle, Mama stepped back, folded her arms across her middle, and nodded toward the boat. Even with emotion waging a war against the composure on her face, Augusta, Lady Telford was the image of a grace Libby could never make herself aspire to, despite admiring it in her mother. “Enjoy yourself, my darling. Try not to ruin too many dresses. And do make an effort to see who from our acquaintances are summering there and send me a wire with their names. I’ll make any introductions I can through telegrams and letters.”

“Yes, Mama.” She’d make an effort. It would be a paltry one, but Mama wouldn’t honestly expect anything more from her. Libby grinned, leaned over to kiss her mother’s cheek, and waited.

Mama swallowed. Gave her another smile that was trying too hard. “Off you go, then. Don’t miss the ferry. Moon, I’m trusting you to see my daughter is well cared for.”

Mabena’s nod was solemn. Though when Mama waved them onward, Libby exchanged a grin with her maid that nearly gave way to a squeal of excitement. Mabena must be excited to see her family again. And Libby . . . Libby could hardly believe that she’d actually pulled this off. She’d actually let a cottage for the summer without her brother’s knowledge. She’d actually get to put a few leagues of distance between herself and the society that had decided she wasn’t quite what they were looking for in an earl’s sister.

Another call from the ship’s bell had her and Mabena both picking up their pace, each clutching the smaller bags they carried with one hand and using the other to hang on to their hats, since the wind was greedily trying to steal them. A laugh spilled from Libby’s lips as they charged up the gangway at a pace too quick to be ladylike.

But that didn’t matter. Not now. They were on their way.

Once aboard, Mabena let out a gusty breath of relief. “There, now. We made it. And not a moment too soon.”

Indeed, with a final clang, the gangway was taken in and the ferry pulled away. Libby took up position at the rails so she could wave to Mama. Her mother blew her a kiss and shouted something that was lost to wind and water slapping the hull and the steam engine’s chug and clamor. Good wishes, no doubt, to match her brave smile.

Libby held her place for a minute more and then spun to take in the world. St. Michael’s Mount, its causeway currently under water, jutted out of the sea to her left, the ancient castle reigning over the small town of Marazion. Gulls swooped and called. And likely countless fish darted beneath the waves, if she could but see them.

Beside her, Mabena chuckled and placed a restraining hand upon her arm. “Easy now, Lady Elizabeth. We don’t need you falling in to get a closer look.”

Libby shot her friend a smile. “No more of that—not this summer. It’ll just be us, Mabena. No one even needs to know that I’m Bram’s sister. I think . . . I think I’ll just be Libby until we go home again. Libby Sinclair. No ‘my lady’ nonsense.”

She expected a smile of pleasure. A nod. Quick agreement. Instead, thunder flashed through Mabena’s deep brown eyes. “That will never do, my lady. You are His Lordship’s sister. You can’t just pretend otherwise. And I had better not either, lest I forget myself when we go back to Somerset.”

For a long moment, Libby just listened to the splash of water as the boat sliced through it, wishing one of her magnifying glasses could help her see what this heavy thing was inside her chest. Wishing there were a Latin name for the feeling of disappointment—no, discomfort. No . . . she didn’t know the word for this feeling that always seized her when someone disapproved of her.

Which was all the time, lately. She could all but see her sister’s perfect face looking at her in utter dismay, hear her voice saying, “For heaven’s sake, Elizabeth, can’t you just be a proper young lady for a day in your life?”

Mabena’s sigh joined the wind jostling them for elbow space at the rail, and she leaned closer until their shoulders just brushed. “You know it isn’t that I don’t want to be so informal, my lady. It’s just that it would be so easy to do that I honestly do fear I’d forget myself when we go back again. And I don’t relish losing this position when your mum or brother realize we’re friends. We walk a fine enough line as it is.”

She knew that. She did. As indulgent as Mama was about the microscope and slides and endless supply of sketchbooks, she wouldn’t budge on some things—the lines between the classes high on the list. Loyalty and some affection between a lady’s maid and a lady was acceptable. Friendship was something else. Friendship required equality, and that she’d never grant.

Were she a braver girl, Libby would defy that unspoken dictate and argue the point. She’d declare that she didn’t care who Mabena’s parents were or where she was from, they were friends and that was that. They understood each other. Shared a fascination with the natural world—something Libby couldn’t claim about any of the gentlemen’s daughters she knew. While they recoiled in horror at a worm or an insect, she leaned in for a closer look. They were too different.

In those ways, Mabena was much more like her. But in others, they were different too. She did need to protect her position—something Libby never had to worry about. She’d better remember that and help her guard it. With a matching sigh, Libby nodded.

“Now, you needn’t look so sad, my lady. St. Mary’s is one of the prettiest places on earth, and you’re going to have a fine time cataloguing every creature and plant you can find. Don’t worry so over a trifle like what name I’ll call you.” Mabena’s eyes, when Libby looked over at her, flashed with laughter. “Perhaps I’ll just take up calling you Mea Domina. That’s your Latin designation, isn’t it?”

Libby laughed and then leaned over the rail again to watch the world swimming by beneath them. Not that she could see much through the froth of their wake, but the glimpses were fascinating. She ought to have convinced her family to spend more time at the seashore. How lucky Mabena was to have grown up with such variety of life at her fingertips. “I’m looking forward to meeting your family. They’ll be there to greet the ferry, right?”

“Ah . . .” Mabena cleared her throat in a way Libby had never heard her do before. She lifted her gaze from the water to her friend’s face. It had a strange look upon it. A bit sheepish. A bit . . . guilty? “It was a friend of mine who sent that telegram, my lady, not my mother. My family’s all on Tresco. We’ll be summering on St. Mary’s. Not that the two aren’t close enough to go between—by boat—and I’m sure you will meet them, but they’re not down the lane as I led your mother to believe.”

“Then why . . . ?” She didn’t even know what to ask. Where to begin. She felt no stab of anxiety over realizing there wouldn’t be a family a few paces away to see to her comfort and care—that hardly mattered. But hadn’t Mabena’s idea for a visit sprung from the desire to see her family again?

“Tresco’s too small to support as many tourists. We’d never have found a place to let there at such a late date.” The twinkle returned to Mabena’s dark eyes. “And besides—there’s a reason I left the isles. Being near family is all well and good, but being able to breathe without them asking if you find the air satisfactory has its merits too. A bit of distance between us and them will be a good thing.”

She could hardly argue with that, given her reasons for wanting this holiday. Perhaps Mabena had a brother like Bram. Not that she’d ever mentioned any siblings. Or really spoken much of her family at all, come to think of it.

The Story Continues on BooksBarbecue!

Enjoyed this preview? ❤️ Do not stop here!

Read the complete book free online → 🔗

Continue reading now on BooksBarbecue and discover every page!

Love reading? Bookmark BooksBarbecue.com for more amazing books!

Happy Reading!