“I really hate to agree with him,” Pine spoke from the other side of the room. “But if anyone knows how a sick fish Fiveson operates, well, it takes one to know one.”

Caledonia had been prepared for resistance. It didn’t surprise her that it was coming from Oran and Pine, but that didn’t make it any less frustrating.

“I assume he’ll turn on us eventually.” Caledonia refused to back down. “But I’m not proposing a lasting alliance, only a temporary one. We work together long enough to take down Lir, then we go our separate ways.”

“We’ll be putting ourselves in a very vulnerable position.” Oran’s eyes were cutting.

“In this case, I think it’s worth the risk.”

The silence that bloomed between Oran and Caledonia was thick. There were things he wanted to say and would not here in front of her crew. Things he would only say to her.

Pine looked shrewdly from Caledonia to Oran, then stepped forward, crowding Oran in the already cramped space. “Care to share with the group?”

Without backing down, Oran responded with a measured blink of his eyes. “If I had something to say, I’d say it.”

The two young men were inches apart. Pine was broad, and his hands curled into heavy fists at his sides, but there was something dangerous in the loose coil of Oran’s body.

“But can we actually trust a Fiveson?” Pisces asked, spearing the tension.

Everyone turned to her in surprise. For a second, silence hung in the air, then Caledonia began to laugh. It started as a small throaty sound, but quickly pushed slightly hysterical tears into her eyes.

“Pi,” she said. “You are the one who told me to trust—”

“Oran!” Pisces shouted. “I told you to trust Oran! Not the entire league of Fivesons! And I didn’t know he was a Fiveson at the time or I’d have been much more specific!”

Caledonia’s smile faded. “I don’t trust Tassos and I’m not suggesting that we should, but I do have confidence that he will act in his own best interest.” Caledonia shifted her gaze back to Oran, who watched her with a shuttered expression. “I think he’ll see the benefit of a temporary alliance with one of Lir’s other enemies.”

Oran didn’t speak right away. He had that faraway look he got when he was revisiting his past. After a long minute, he drew in a breath and fixed Caledonia with narrowed eyes. “There’s no one he hates more than Lir.”

That was exactly what Caledonia wanted to hear. “Then we have something in common.”

If we leave this place, how will other survivors find us? Hime asked, stepping away from the wall where she’d been listening with one hand pressed against her mouth.