“So if I thought that what had actually happened was that Thurston had structured his proposals to understate the probability of a real fight in order to, um, entice the Octagon and the Committee into letting him try it despite the fact that he actually planned on fighting a serious battle, I’d have a lot more respect for him. Citizen Admiral Theisman or Citizen Admiral Giscard—or Citizen Secretary McQueen—might have done that. But if they had, they also would have carried through even if they knew their official diversionary strategy hadn’t completely succeeded. Unfortunately, I think what happened was that Thurston really came up with a bad operational concept—or a weak one, at least—which simply happened to fit the profile of the ’low risk’ counterattack for which his superiors were searching. He wasn’t looking for a fight; he genuinely believed he could avoid one—have his cake and eat it too, if you will—and put his foot straight into it.

“The difference here is that Citizen Secretary McQueen isn’t particularly interested in tricking the enemy into doing anything. Instead, she intends to take advantage of things the enemy’s already done. And unlike Thurston or Citizen Secretary Kline, she’s willing to take a few risks to win. So she expects us to actually do some serious fighting when we reach our objectives, but she’s picked those objectives to give us the best shot of achieving our mission goals anyway.”

“But Zanzibar has been a Manty ally for almost ten T-years now,” Honeker pointed out. “That’s why the Alliance put its new shipyard there, and they’ve picketed it since before Parks took Seaforth Nine away from us.”

“They certainly have,” Tourville agreed, “but at the moment, they’re in very much the position we were in when Thurston launched Operation Dagger, if for rather different reasons. They’ve got an awful big chunk of their wall of battle in for overhaul at the very moment when they’re strategically overextended by their successes. That means they can’t possibly be strong everywhere—just as we couldn’t—because they simply don’t have the ships for it. And that means that someplace like Zanzibar, which is so far behind the front, and where there have been no active operations by either side for over eight years, is going to be lightly covered. They’ll have enough firepower on call to deal with a raiding battlecruiser squadron or two… but that’s why we have three battleship squadrons along for support.”

Tourville paused once more, watching Honeker’s eyes, then shrugged.

“Frankly,” he said, “this is something we should have done years ago, Sir. We lost a lot of battleships trying to stop the Manties short of Trevor’s Star, but we’ve still got over two hundred of them, and our superdreadnought strength has been rising again for the last T-year or so. That means we ought to be using the battleships as aggressively as possible. Since they aren’t suitable for the wall of battle—and since our growing SD strength means we can finally stop putting them into it anyway—they should be committed to a strategy of deep raids. They’ve got the accel to run away from SDs and dreadnoughts and the firepower to squash battlecruisers. That makes them pretty damned close to the ideal tool to keep the Manties thinking about the security of their rear areas. And every ship of the wall we can force them to divert to guarding a star twenty or thirty light-years behind the front is just as much out of action as one we’ve blown apart. That’s what Icarus is all about. What we’d prefer to do is to actually gain the initiative for the first time since the war began, but even if we don’t, we should at least take the initiative away from the Manties. And that, Citizen Commissioner, is a damned sight better than anything we’ve managed yet!”