His delicacy was admirable, but this was an enquiry that could either define guilt or pronounce innocence, and even to the dead, that was important. Monk could not afford to leave anything unprobed or go about his questions in the least offensive way if it was also the least efficient.

"You were aware of her unhappiness?" he asked as gently as he could.

"Mr. Havilland died less than two months ago," Cardman said stiffly. "Grief does not heal so soon."

It was a socially correct answer, giving away nothing and delivered with as much disapproval as a butler dared show.

Monk was brutal. "Is your father still alive, Mr. Cardman?"

Cardman's face tightened, the light of understanding flaming in his eyes, bright and angry. "No, sir."

Monk smiled. "I'm sure you grieved for him, but you did not despair." He thought briefly that part of the loss of his memory from the accident included complete obliteration of anything about his own father, or mother, for that matter. He knew only his sister, Beth, and that only because she had tried to keep in touch. He wrote seldom. The shame of that bit into him without warning, and he felt the heat in his face.

"No, sir," Cardman said stiffly.

Monk sat down in one of the big leather armchairs and crossed his legs. "Mr. Cardman, I mean to find out whether this was suicide or something else," he said levelly. "I have investigated deaths of many kinds, and I do not give up until I have what I seek. You will assist me, willingly or not. You can remain standing if you wish, but I prefer that you sit. I don't like staring up at you."

Cardman obeyed. Monk noticed a rigidity in his movement, as if he were unused to sitting in the presence of a guest, and certainly not in this room. He had probably been a servant all his life, perhaps starting as a boot boy forty years ago, or more. Yet he could have spent time in the army. There was a ramrod stiffness to him, a sense of dignity as well as self-discipline.

"Were you surprised?" Monk asked suddenly.

Cardman's eyes widened. "Surprised?"

"That Miss Havilland should throw herself off Waterloo Bridge?"

"Yes, sir. We all were."

"What was she like? Retiring or opinionated? Intelligent or not?" Monk was determined to get a meaningful answer from the man, not the bland words of praise a servant would normally give his employer, or anyone would accord to the dead. "Was she pretty? Did she flirt? Was she in love with Mr. Argyll, or did she perhaps prefer someone else? Might she have felt trapped in a marriage to him?"

"Trapped?" Cardman was startled.