“I didn’t fuck your sister! I was in the shower this morning. You stumbled to Taylor’s room, so I slept in there with you. I held you in my arms all fucking night. Taylor must have slept in my room and your psychotic sister must have crawled in bed with him, thinking it was me. You caught Finley with Taylor!”

I frowned, knowing I could tell them apart by now, but I had just woken up and was upset. Maybe…

“Just let me come up. Please? I’m gonna start losing fingers soon.”

“You’re going to let Taylor take the fall for you? This is beyond fooling your teachers in school, don’t you think?”

“I swear to God. Just let me come up so I can explain. We’ll call Taylor if you want.”

“He would lie for you.”

“Ellie, please? It’s my birthday.” His dimple appeared, but I stayed strong.

“Then go find your brother and celebrate it.”

He shook his head, smiling. “I want to spend it with you. Even if that means I spend the day trying to figure out what the hell happened last night.”

“It’s two degrees, Tyler.”

“Then let me in,” he said, his smile fading. “I can’t leave. It’ll ruin my whole day.”

“I think you ruined your day when you slept with my sister!”

“I didn’t sleep with your sister! Goddammit!” he yelled, kicking the door.

“Stop! Wick will kick me out!”

Tyler perched his hands on his hips, breathing hard. He shook his head, and then looked up. “Open this door, Ellie, or I’ll kick it in, I swear to God.”

“You’re a bastard,” I said.

He held out his hands. “And your sister’s a bitch.”

I closed the window and stomped downstairs, twisting the bolt lock and opening the door. Tyler passed me, jogging up to the apartment. By the time I walked into the living room, he was shivering on my sofa, wrapped in the comforter off my bed.

I rolled my eyes and turned on the Keurig.

“I almost got hypothermia over this,” he said.

“You should have dressed warmly,” I snapped.

“I didn’t have much time, considering my brother busts into the bathroom to tell me a half-ass version of the story, and I had to run after you in a towel down the block and then back. I grabbed the first clothes I saw, put them on, and ran out the door. The only woman I touched last night was you. You have to believe me.”

“I’m making you a cup of coffee, and then you’re leaving.”

Tyler stood. “C’mon! You know this isn’t right! Think about it!”

I let my hands fall to my thighs. “So what? My sister came back and deduced it was your room because of our pictures on the wall, undressed, and climbed into bed with a sleeping, naked Taylor?”