Back After She Left Save as PDF
Chapters (37)
  1. AFTER SHE LEFT
  2. Author’s note:
  3. Chapter One
  4. Chapter Two
  5. Chapter Three
  6. Chapter Four
  7. Chapter Five
  8. Chapter Six
  9. Chapter Seven
  10. Chapter Eight
  11. Chapter Nine
  12. Chapter Ten
  13. Chapter Eleven
  14. Chapter Twelve
  15. Chapter Thirteen
  16. Chapter Fourteen
  17. Chapter Fifteen
  18. Chapter Sixteen
  19. Chapter Seventeen
  20. Chapter Eighteen
  21. Chapter Nineteen
  22. Chapter Twenty
  23. Chapter Twenty-One
  24. Chapter Twenty-Two
  25. Chapter Twenty-Three
  26. Chapter Twenty-Four
  27. Chapter Twenty-Five
  28. Chapter Twenty-Six
  29. Chapter Twenty-Seven
  30. Chapter Twenty-Eight
  31. Chapter Twenty-Nine
  32. Chapter Thirty
  33. Chapter Thirty-One
  34. Chapter Thirty-Two
  35. Chapter Thirty-Three
  36. Chapter Thirty-Four
  37. The Silent Daughter

“Okay,” he says. “So what does your voice say?”

I hesitate. Given where I’ve been leading this conversation, it’s not really a question I can avoid. But my hands are suddenly sweating. And because of how much I don’t want to answer this question honestly, I realize just how brave Sam is being with us right now.

“Well,” I say slowly. “Sometimes I’ll make a mistake, and then my voice will tell me how stupid I am.” I clear my throat. “It’ll tell me that everybody knows how stupid I am and that they think I’m a fool. And ridiculous. Or…” I hesitate. This really is humiliating, and I’m starting to wish Oliver wasn’t in the room. “Or I’ll look in the mirror and the voice will say things like look at all those wrinkles, or look how fat your arms are. Nobody wants to look at you.”

I feel Oliver’s startled eyes on me, but I avoid meeting them. Sam, meanwhile, is agog. I’ve come this far now.

“It also likes to tell me,” I say, forcing out the words, “that I’m letting everyone down. That I’m not a very good daughter, or sister, or aunt.” I take a deep breath, and say the last part. “And it tells me the reason I’m not a mom is…is because I wouldn’t be a good enough one.”

I feel Oliver shift in his seat. I focus on Sam’s face instead, his high-alert eyes scanning mine. Children aren’t used to getting admissions like this from adults. Maybe it’s too much. I wonder whether I’ve unnerved him, or made him lose respect for me.

He sits silent for a while, then frowns.

“That’s a different kind of voice, though,” he says finally. “It’s not the same as mine.”

“Well…no,” I agree. “It’s not the same. My voice doesn’t give me orders. Or threaten me. And it’s not always there.” Just on bad days. Just a little too often, recently. “But,” I say, “it’s still a person that lives in my head, that I didn’t invite in, and that doesn’t want the best for me even though it pretends it does. Doesn’t that sound a little crazy to you?”

Sam looks to me, then Oliver, then the floor.

“I don’t know. No. Maybe.”

“They’re just bullies, you know,” I say. “Those voices—they try to tell us they’re our friends. That they’re protecting us; that we need them. But they’re actually just bullies.”

Sam’s silent for a while. Slowly, he nods. We sit for a while, saying nothing.

“I guess you haven’t said anything about this to your parents?” I ask quietly.

He looks away.

“There’s nothing they can do. I’m just like this.”

I swallow a lump in my throat.